What management can and cannot refuse — and your step-by-step path from appeal to Tribunal if the rejection is unlawful.
This guide is for general information only and is not legal advice. For your specific situation, confirm with the Commissioner of Buildings, the Strata Management Tribunal, or a qualified Malaysian lawyer.
When you own a strata parcel — whether a condominium, serviced apartment, or strata-titled townhouse — you have a qualified right to renovate your own unit. The qualification is that you must obtain written approval from the Joint Management Body (JMB) or Management Corporation (MC) first.
The primary rule is By-law 27 of the Third Schedule to the Strata Management (Maintenance and Management) Regulations 2015 (Source: Strata Management (Maintenance & Management) Regulations 2015, Third Schedule, By-law 27). It states that a proprietor shall not carry out any renovation works to his parcel without first obtaining prior written approval from the management corporation and, where necessary, from the appropriate local authority.
The management body’s powers to regulate renovations flow from Section 70 of the Strata Management Act 2013 (Act 757), which allows the MC to make additional by-laws by special resolution to regulate use and enjoyment of parcels and common property (Source: Strata Management Act 2013, s.70(2)). However, those powers are not unlimited — by-laws must be reasonable and cannot strip owners of their fundamental parcel rights.
Your building’s house rules may add further conditions on top of the standard Third Schedule by-laws. Always request a copy of both the registered by-laws and the current house rules from management before submitting your application.
Management bodies are entitled to set reasonable conditions to protect the structural integrity of the building, the safety of other residents, and the appearance of the common property. The following requirements are standard and lawful:
| Requirement | Legal basis | Typical amount / scope |
|---|---|---|
| Renovation deposit | By-law 27, Third Schedule, SM(M&M) Regs 2015 | RM500 – RM2,000 (refundable if no common-property damage) |
| Submission of renovation plan | By-law 27; building house rules | Floor plan + scope of works + contractor details |
| Approved working hours only | Third Schedule by-laws; local authority noise rules | Typically Mon–Sat 9am–5pm or 8am–6pm |
| No structural alterations without authority approval | By-law 27(3); National Land Code; local authority | Load-bearing wall removal requires SE endorsement |
| No facade or exterior changes | By-law 27(2); s.70 SMA 2013 | Windows, external walls, balconies |
| Contractor indemnity / insurance letter | House rules (common in larger developments) | Proof contractor holds public liability insurance |
These conditions exist to protect all residents and are enforceable. Comply with them in full before arguing the refusal is unlawful.
Management cannot lawfully reject a renovation application simply because it dislikes the owner, because the owner has an outstanding dispute with management, or for no stated reason at all. The following types of rejection are likely to be successfully challenged:
MahWengKwai & Associates has noted that management bodies sometimes impose conditions that go well beyond their statutory powers; in those cases the correct remedy is the Strata Management Tribunal, not compliance (Source: MahWengKwai & Associates, “Strata Management Tribunal Malaysia” overview).
| Condition imposed by management | Likely lawful? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Refundable renovation deposit (RM500–RM2,000) | Yes | Expressly contemplated by By-law 27, Third Schedule |
| Restricting works to Mon–Sat, 9am–5pm | Yes | By-law noise obligations; local-authority hours |
| Requiring submission of contractor’s public liability insurance | Yes | Reasonable protection of common property and third parties |
| Requiring SE endorsement for structural wall removal | Yes | Building safety; National Land Code structural obligations |
| Non-refundable “admin fee” of RM3,000–RM10,000 | Likely not | Not contemplated by Third Schedule; may be ultra vires |
| Blanket ban on all wet-area works (e.g. bathroom tiling) | Likely not | No statutory basis; unreasonably restricts parcel use |
| Refusal to state reasons in writing | No | Owners entitled to written reasons to exercise appeal rights |
| Approval conditional on settling an unrelated service-charge dispute | No | Improper purpose; bad-faith exercise of management powers |
Follow these steps in order before escalating to formal bodies:
The stronger your paper trail, the stronger your Tribunal claim. Gather the following before filing:
For contractor vetting and written contracts, see our renovation contract guide → and how to choose a renovation contractor →.
The Commissioner of Buildings (COB) is appointed under the SMA 2013 to oversee and enforce compliance by JMBs and MCs. COB offices are administered at the local authority level (e.g. DBKL for Kuala Lumpur; various Majlis Bandaraya/Perbandaran for Selangor) (Source: KPKT, Commissioner of Buildings portal, kpkt.gov.my).
To file a complaint:
The COB route is lower-cost than the Tribunal but the timeframes are less predictable. For a binding, enforceable order, the Tribunal is faster.
The Strata Management Tribunal (SMT), administered by KPKT, is the specialist forum for strata disputes in Malaysia. It handles claims up to RM250,000 and is deliberately designed to be accessible without a lawyer (Source: MahWengKwai & Associates, “10 Things to Know About the Strata Management Tribunal”; KPKT, [email protected]).
How to file:
For the full procedure, see our companion guide: Strata Management Tribunal: how to file a claim →. Also see: How to file a strata management complaint in Malaysia →.
| Route | Cost | Typical timeline | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Formal appeal to JMB/MC committee | Nil (do it yourself) | 2–4 weeks | Approval, rejection, or silence |
| COB complaint | Nil to low | 4–12 weeks (variable) | Directive to management; no damages |
| Strata Management Tribunal | RM100 filing fee; no lawyer required | 6–16 weeks to award | Binding order; can include damages or refund of unlawful deposits |
| Civil court (High Court) | Lawyer fees (RM8,000–RM30,000+) | 1–3+ years | Full judicial review; for complex matters beyond RM250k |
If your renovation involves structural works (e.g. removing a wall, relocating a beam, or hacking the floor slab), the requirements are more stringent and management is entitled to require more documentation. This is not an unlawful rejection — it is a legitimate safety requirement.
For structural changes, expect management to require:
Facade changes (altering the exterior appearance of your unit — e.g. replacing windows with a different profile, installing a different type of grille, enclosing a balcony) are subject to By-law 27(2) of the Third Schedule, which prohibits changes to the exterior or facade without prior written management approval. Management can legitimately refuse facade changes to maintain a uniform building appearance. For more on hacking walls and structural works, see hacking walls in Malaysia: what you need to know →.
A professional contractor who understands strata renovation rules can dramatically smooth the approval process. They will know what documentation management typically requires, can provide the standard letter of indemnity, and can prepare a renovation plan that addresses management’s usual concerns upfront.
Before engaging a contractor for a strata renovation:
For scam-proofing and contract safeguards, see renovation scam red flags → and renovation contract essentials →. You can also use our free renovation contract generator →.
Tell us what you need — we reply within the hour.